I seem to gravitate towards All + Hot lately. This gives me a really nice variety of posts. All + Top 6 Hour is good as well.
I’ve been subscribing to a lot of communities, but find that I often don’t browse by subscription. I mainly use subscriptions to bookmark communities in case I want to view them individually.
I’ve joined an instance that has a good number of communities I like (feddit.de).
Then I’ve subscribed to a smallish number of communities I’m especially interested in, but only on other instances.
And I keep banning communities I’m not interested in when they pop up on all.
Now I spend about equal times in subscribed/new, local/new and all/hot, and they each show me things I’m interested in, but more or less specific.